On 27th February 2000,
mother of three Suzanne Viguier disappeared without a trace.
Her husband, Jacques Viguier, was soon suspected of her murder.
9 years later,
he was tried for the murder of his wife.
...with complete honesty the impression made on them
by the evidence against the accused and the arguments in his defence.
The law asks them but one question,
which sums up the extent of their duty:
"Are you absolutely convinced?"
Mr Viguier, you must wait in court until a verdict is reached.
Ladies and gentlemen of the jury, please come with me.
After deliberating for three hours,
the nine jurors answered "no"...
Jacques Viguier was acquitted today.
This law professor was accused of killing...
The prosecution demanded 15 to 20 years...
I'm sure the jury was in no doubt that Viguier was guilty, but...
Jacques Viguier has been acquitted. He'll sleep at home tonight.
But the law professor isn't done with the courts yet.
We learnt late this morning that there'll be another Viguier trial.
The Toulouse public prosecutor has appealed.
The law professor...
It's quite shocking
for the prosecution to appeal against the jury's verdict.
But they have the right.
So there'll be another trial in 2010.
What will happen if he's found guilty and sentenced?
- All right? - Yeah.
- Was it good? - Yeah. Thanks.
- Did you play well? - Yeah.
Sorry we're late.
- Hi. - All right?
- Filou, homework first, shower after. - Yeah.
There, write "250". I'll do it for you.
It's important to know how to do this.
- So what's that the mass of? - The page.
What's the point of knowing the mass of a page?
Just work it out, it's easy.
- To find out the mass of a page? - Yes.
I didn't set the problem.
That's the sort of lawyer your dad needs.
He's got people off in some very complicated cases.
- Will you talk to him? - Yeah.
He's in a down phase. It could be a while.
- Bye. - See you.
Any news about Melun?
All right. Yeah, fine.
- Matre Dupond-Moretti? - Hello, Madam.
I called about the Viguier case.
I have nothing to do with it. In your job you should do some research.
I'm not a journalist.
I'd like you to take the case.
Where will it be?
I don't shake hands with the court president.
He's dishonest. He's convicted two that I got off in a first trial.
When is it?
- In March. - March?
No, I can't, it's impossible.
They don't even know she's dead. Maybe she just ran away.
The case is all hearsay.
And the press were disgusting.
There's no body, no evidence, no motive.
But I have no time.
And I can't just take the case at the last moment.
For too long we've tolerated the irresponsibility of some parents...
- Don't you understand French? - It's all in here.
I'd need the court file.
This is better. I dissected the first trial.
- What are you doing? - You know what they accuse him of?
I should be in Montauban already.
Let me park my car and I'll come with you.
- No. - This is a miscarriage of justice.
That's enough, now get out.
If he wanted a new lawyer, he'd ask me himself!
He can't, he's sick!
All right, wait!
What's she up to?
Table number 6, one person. The chicken, please.
Take that! If it's cold, the customer won't come again.
- Do you enjoy terrorising her? - That's how they learn.
- I have a bit of time later. - How much is "a bit"?
About two hours, shower included.
I can hardly wait!
Tell me how much I owe you!
See you tomorrow.
You've got one there.
- What? - A cushion.
You're not a sharer!
You won't share your cushion.
Am I bothering you?
Go for it!
It's ric Dupond-Moretti. How are you?
I'm fine. Hello.
You want to see me?
I don't know, Bordeaux's a bit tricky.
At this number?
He's not even local. How will that help him?
An innocent man doesn't change lawyers.
I'm not talking to you.
Jacques Viguier changes his lawyer
Can I still get something to eat?
Sorry, the kitchens closed two hours ago.
I'll see what I can do, but...
I talked to Viguier on the phone. Do you know him or not?
- I'm a friend of Clmence. - That's what he told me.
And he lets a friend of Clmence interfere in his case?
I was at the first trial.
How do you know Clmence? She's only 20.
What's this, the third degree?
I need to know who I'm dealing with.
She teaches my son maths.
We talked, one thing led to another...
She's affected me, I can't help it.
This is all pretty unusual.
I read your notes.
There's interesting stuff here.
But I can't use it in court.
- Why? - I can't mention the first trial.
But you worked hard on it.
- What's your job? - Chef.
Honest! I'm a chef in a brasserie in Toulouse.
You should come for lunch.
All I can serve you is some charcuterie, I'm sorry.
There's some crme brle too.
- You like that, I believe. - All right.
And a drop of champagne.
- Bon apptit! - Thank you.
They've spoilt you!
What a bloody life!
I had a reconciliation with Richiardi.
The Albi court president. He was quite pleasant on the phone.
there's still this rumour about him.
He so hates his colleague in Toulouse that he quashes guilty verdicts
and overturns acquittals.
- But there are the jurors. - Yeah.
do you want to help me?
Yes, I'd like to help.
Richiardi has been magnanimous
with the phone-tapping recordings.
250 hours of recordings.
My predecessors begged for them, and he hands them over
six weeks before the trial.
Obviously I can't listen to them all.
Do you feel up to the job?
Don't you have an army of juniors for that?
I have two, working on the cases I had to dump.
There's no one who knows the case as well as you do.
All you have to do is listen and note anything interesting.
Can you help or not?
Well, I'd like to but...
I'm going skiing with my son in just over a week, and...
It's a big responsibility.
That's for sure.
But you already took on that responsibility
when you came looking for me.
What's on the recordings?
Viguier's phone, his parents'
and the lover's. He talks a lot.
- What do you think of the lover? - Durandet?
What do you want me to think? He's adamant that Viguier is guilty.
He requested me when he associated with the prosecution. I refused.
At the first trial he was convincing, he seemed sincere.
He moved everyone, he cried.
And the husband convinces no one.
He's bipolar, that's how it is.
It's the worst sort of situation for me.
He's been acquitted once.
If he isn't this time, everyone'll say it's my fault.
You've got the case file. There's nothing in it, right?
Yeah, they've got sod all!
But court cases are delicate.
Why do you think the prosecutor appealed?
They've had their culprit for ten years.
If they want to destroy him, they will.
- Hello. - Olivier?
- Yeah. - Hi.
- Hi. - How are you?
What's the matter?
Well, Suzy disappeared a fortnight ago and...
- What do you mean? - Well...
You know what I think?
Yes, her husband killed her.
Don't say that.
He was released from custody at 6:30 this morning.
The bastard didn't confess.
There are suspicions, accusations...
There's no proof, but lots of stuff points to him.
- It's not possible! - I'm afraid it is.
How do you come into all this?
As Suzy's lover and because I'm really worried.
- But if he did it in cold blood... - It's worse.
We're practically sure that it was premeditated.
Did she just disappear overnight?
We were at the cards tournament. I took her home on the Sunday at 5 a.m.
Not a word since then.
What about the children?
Their grandfather picked them up that Sunday morning at 10:15.
Jacques supposedly went for a jog,
had a shower and went out in his car
while his wife slept.
They slept apart. She was sleeping in their office room.
Oh, she was sleeping in the...
And he joined his children for lunch at 12:30.
What if she just left?
She couldn't have, she didn't take anything
and her car's in the garage.
But I'm going to phone everyone who agrees with me.
- We won't let it go. - Shit!
I'm going to harass the guy,
it'll be in the paper,
I'll spread rumours...
You can't do that.
- I can't do what? - You can't spread...
It's not like I'm going to sign the rumours.
Has Mr Dupond-Moretti gone?
Yes. He usually leaves at dawn and returns late.
Do you want to leave him a message?
I consider myself more like Suzy's companion.
I'm a "lover", strictly speaking,
because they're still married, but I'm not making her unfaithful.
There's nothing between them.
So there's no cheating. He's her husband...
Maybe he knew about you two and that's why he did it.
No. They had a talk a month ago and he understood...
- That she wanted a divorce? - Yeah.
She disappeared on Sunday 27th February.
On the Monday she had an appointment with a lawyer.
Five people have confirmed that.
Jacques must have thought,
"I'm losing my wife, I'm losing my kids,
"I'm losing my house...
"What will they say about me at uni?
"What will my parents think? What will people say?"
The fact of losing all that, in public,
and the failure of a divorce,
moving back in with his parents like a 20-year-old...
You scared me!
What are you doing?
sit down, I have something to tell you.
You know the brilliant lawyer I went looking for?
He asked me to help him to defend Clmence's dad.
It's a big job he's asked of me.
I want to do it,
but it means I can't come skiing with you.
But I talked to Gaspard's mum and she's fine with it being you two.
It's not a problem.
But I can't come.
It's all right.
Shall we order some sushi?
I can't tell you everything, but they found her handbag.
In the house.
- They found her handbag? - In the house.
With the keys to the house in the handbag.
Tell me how, with the doors locked and shutters down,
you can get out of your house and leave the keys inside?
He got details off the cops and leaked them to witnesses.
That could be subornation. Transcribe it all.
I'm over there.
It's confusing. I get lost with all the people he talks to.
Identify them well. We'll see them all in court.
How long is there until the trial? A month?
About that. So work hard.
Got the GoPro?
- Did you finish your maths? - Yeah.
Clmence, does the name Philippe ring a bell?
- He's my godfather. - Great!
That's one of the three Philippes.
- I'll play the second. - I don't know any others.
What about Sylvie?
One of Mum's colleagues, a dancing teacher.
But I was only 10 years old.
Thanks for everything you're doing.
See you Thursday.
Hello, Olivier? It's Audrey.
- You gave a statement? - Yes.
Good, they got in touch.
- Is your surname Friasse? - Fraisse.
I thought it was you.
- I gave them your number. - Oh, right.
From Suzy's address book.
Philippe, it's Olivier.
- Hello? - Hello, Ambre?
Hello, it's Olivier.
- Laetitia? - Yes.
Hello. Sorry to bother you,
but I'd like to speak to...
What you can say is that your dancing teacher disappeared
and that her husband is in custody.
We'll talk to the parents,
who may tell their kids.
And the parents might discuss it at work.
I'm interested in the students. Rumours at uni spread fast.
It'll spread in Villefranche like wildfire.
Can we accuse someone without proof?
You mustn't say, "He killed her." What you can say is,
"I think... that he killed her."
It's a supposition, not an assertion.
- Right. - You can't be done for slander.
You're through to Olivier Durandet. Please leave a message.
Mr Durandet, this is La Dpche du Midi.
First I have to polish up the article with the cop,
then with the journalist.
First you have to create the suspense.
- "Strange disappearance." - Yes.
Short and snappy.
Bullet points. "Her keys were still inside.
"Did she walk through the walls?"
I don't expect to find her with the posters.
They're to put pressure on him, so he'll see that people are active.
Even the children.
It really distresses me that they're suffering.
But they're bound to suffer anyway,
so we have to use that.
They're suffering now and we're going to make it worse,
but if it makes Jacques confess, we have to do it.
It's in Le Figaro, Libration, Le Parisien, La...
Yeah, I saw.
And a journalist from Dtectives came to see me.
Cases lose their focus when the tabloids get involved.
Even if there are false rumours, that's not a problem.
Tongues have to wag to keep up the pressure,
whatever they're saying.
At uni, a year ago, he boasted he could commit the perfect crime.
A perfect crime?
I'm sure he was inspired by Hitchcock's films...
He's a big fan of Hitchcock.
Court is in session. You may be seated.
Ladies and gentlemen of the jury,
I'll bring your attention to the fact that we are not only judging an act.
Above all, we are judging a man.
Hello, Mr Viguier.
Hello, Mr President.
Mr Viguier, over these three weeks
we shall try to be as thorough as possible.
But, before that,
I want to go over one point.
You're a film lover.
I've read your writings about cinema but have found nothing about Hitchcock.
Yet it is said that you're a fan of the English director.
It's like the lectures about the perfect crime.
Closer to the microphone.
- Closer to the microphone. - Sorry.
- I said... - Switch it on.
It's like my supposed lectures about the perfect crime.
It was part of the media's rumour-mongering.
I like Hitchcock, but I'm no expert.
westerns and musicals.
There isn't a Hitchcock film of which your case reminds you?
- The Lady Vanishes? - Yes, but I was thinking of another.
Don't you see?
The Wrong Man.
It came out in 1957.
The year you were born.
Mr Viguier, in your first statement you said
that your wife seemed fragile
and depressed. Your words.
Why did you say that?
Was she on medication? Was she seeing a doctor?
No, but as an example, she once said to Clmence,
"Your dad gave me AIDS."
Do you think that telling such a lie to a ten-year-old
is a sign of wellbeing?
Suzy's mother said, "I don't want to believe she's dead.
"I believe she's still alive."
But Suzy's sisters are convinced that Viguier murdered her.
Suzy's two sisters are associating with the prosecution.
They believe she wanted a divorce, which Jacques couldn't accept.
I'm waiting for him to be sentenced.
We have to think of our sister, Suzy.
She's dead, she didn't see her children grow.
I was 100% sure he did it before. But now...
I'm 300% sure, if not more.
What do you expect from this trial?
I want to know what happened.
And maybe see my daughter turn up. Who knows?
We're becoming more aware
of the very serious charges against Jacques Viguier.
- Well... - It went well this morning, didn't it?
I'm wary of Richiardi.
He'll bow and scrape, then stab you in the back.
What have you got?
I've sorted some recordings by theme.
That's not what I asked for, I need transcriptions.
- ric. - Francis.
What are you doing here?
It's not a winner!
Your wife disappeared.
And you went skiing.
You asked Mr Durandet to phone the hospitals and friends.
Is that a normal way to act?
Why didn't you ask your neighbours
if they'd seen or heard anything?
Why did you wait such a long time before mentioning your wife's absence
to your colleague?
- Where did you get to? - Nowhere.
What do I do with your CD?
What use are you? I give you discs, you bring back discs.
Don't be so unpleasant.
I found stuff, but I don't know what you can use.
- Where are you going? - With you.
The conversations go on for hours.
So I have to pick out the substance.
Sometimes I go through 3 or 4 calls to find a lie.
How many like this?
Dozens. I've sorted them by theme.
What's in "Connivance with the police"?
Your work is too fine.
A lawyer can't be subtle.
I'm a donkey, I need big bullets.
We can't let Durandet talk. If we give him space, we're screwed.
The same for his hangers-on. We shoot to kill.
The rule is: one sentence, one question, then bang!
He's down. As soon as I speak, bang!
The witness is finished.
Are we out of white paper?
We know it's not true that he went jogging.
But he told me several times that he did go running.
He told me several times.
Yeah, but it's bullshit.
Keep that to yourself.
- I'll try to pop back later. - Thanks.
There's been a persistent rumour
that Viguier never went jogging.
So my question is a simple one. Did you believe he was a sporty person?
I don't know.
I don't remember.
Do you not remember a discussion that you had
with Olivier Durandet about jogging?
- All right? - Hi.
How was your holiday?
Two loins of lamb, please.
- Is this ready? - Yeah.
Is it dangerous to go back in when he's not there?
It'd be breaking and entering. Don't get caught.
"Don't get caught." Spoken by a policeman?
But I told him it was illegal, I told him it would be
breaking and entering.
- Have you seen the time? - I'm sorry.
I'm really sorry.
Get a move on.
The investigating judge was there all Saturday afternoon.
They've got him by the balls.
I asked if he could lock him up with two big black queers.
"I asked if he could lock him up
"with two big black queers."
And you said, "Yeah, that'd be best."
Durandet: "The superintendent said they'd more likely be brown.
"But as they're all queer..."
You added, "We're not responsible for the company he keeps."
- What a laugh, eh? - What are you trying to prove?
What a great humanist you are.
A nuanced fellow.
You're a witness to nothing.
You've taken up with Durandet and you'll stick with him all the way.
Do you mind if I go now?
No. Live your life!
Tell us your name, age and profession.
I live in Toulouse and I work in a bank.
Do you swear to tell the whole truth?
- Raise your hand and say, "I swear." - I swear.
this morning my client saw Mr Durandet talking to other witnesses.
This worries me.
This is strictly forbidden.
Are we sure it was him? She may have been mistaken.
You knew Olivier Durandet,
but you didn't see him earlier today?
Really? You didn't bump into him?
Yes, just bumped into him.
Matre de Caunes?
Did you too bump into Mr Durandet earlier?
Yes, in the caf.
You had a coffee but didn't talk about the case?
I just asked how it was going. I hadn't been following it.
You asked Mr Durandet how the trial was going?
I have no more questions, Mr President.
Bailiff, make sure that Mr Durandet remains a good distance
from the courthouse.
- I'll be offering you a job soon. - I'm not sure I'd accept.
When's Durandet's turn?
End of next week. We have time.
Empty your pockets, please.
Raise your arms.
I'll see you when you get out of prison!
The superintendent said,
"your son is guilty, there's no doubt about it.
"He has two choices.
"Either he confesses
"and, since his wife was a bitch
"who made his life hell,
"there are mitigating circumstances, so he'll get five years.
"Or he doesn't confess
"and in that case he'll be sentenced to...
"And what will become of his children?
"will end up a prostitute,
"will be on drugs
"and their lives will be ruined.
"So, Mr Viguier,
"you're going to help me get your son to confess.
"Then it will be all over."
"No, I'm not going to help you."
He sat down again
behind his desk and said, "We're finished. Of course...
"you won't be allowed to see your son."
Thank you, Mr Viguier.
This is Nora.
I like that! A former juror has joined the Viguier family.
The woman in the jacket.
She was a juror in the first trial.
Can I have a word?
You mugged me off!
Why didn't you tell me you were on the jury?
I had to get you to read my file and I thought that...
it'd scare you off and...
- I was going to tell you. - Oh, yeah? When?
You wouldn't have let me hear the phone recordings.
From now on, you forget me.
When the house was searched,
the investigators found traces of blood
on the banister of the stairs leading to Suzanne Viguier's bedroom.
Blood of both the husband and wife
was found on a piece of cloth in the boot of the car
and also in the bathroom.
It looked like blood in the bath,
as if someone had had a bath,
then let the water out, and traces had stayed in the bathtub.
You say they have no proof, but you're not sure either.
But they're talking crap, exaggerating everything.
The blood was microscopic, it means nothing.
There's blood in our kitchen from me cutting myself. It's nothing.
Why did Viguier get rid of the mattress that his wife slept on?
This is dodgy reporting.
The law professor has an answer for everything.
- Don't let them fool you. - But...
There's no proof. No proof means acquittal.
That's very important.
Or you could send an innocent man to prison.
You have to understand that.
We don't all have to agree with you!
I want to believe in justice and let it run its course.
I've let it do so for nine years, that's a long time.
What I'd like now
is to hear the truth.
Ten days after her disappearance, you reported her as being abducted.
You then went home.
And it was then that you decided to throw the mattress away.
Can you explain that, Mr Viguier?
- Hello. - It's full, Madam.
I was alone at home, for the first time in ages.
The disappearance had...
disturbed my routine.
I was going round in circles.
I started tidying up a bit and I saw the sofa bed.
And... well, it's hard to explain
I was worried about Suzy, but angry at her too.
I guessed she'd been unfaithful, not knowing who but...
So when I saw the sofa bed,
I took the mattress,
in a fit of temper, and threw it away at the dump.
Why did you at first say
that you threw it away
because it was uncomfortable?
I couldn't tell the police the real reason.
You changed your story three times!
Your psychological explanations took eight months to come out.
I'm sorry, but I didn't break my oath or speak about the deliberations.
I can talk to the family if I want.
If anyone is taking a risk, it's me, not you.
You lied to me, I can't trust you.
Get used to it.
You're not coming in the bogs?
Court will reconvene.
Court is in session.
You may be seated.
Mr Viguier, tell us about that Sunday morning.
I got up with my sons.
I went to wake Clmence,
but she wasn't in her room, so I looked...
in her mother's room, and...
she got up and came with me.
But you saw your wife sleeping?
I thought I saw her.
In that room,
when the electric shutters are down,
Your statements became more and more precise,
but now you seem to be refuting what you said.
Did you, yes or no, see your wife in her bedroom?
Clmence was lying down and, behind...
I saw a shape.
You're not exempt from having to stand.
Who said you could speak?
I was about to stand!
I was speaking into the microphone.
- To make it heard. - Well done.
Matre Dupond-Moretti, thank you.
At reference D279, you said,
"I heard my wife's footsteps in the hallway."
She was wearing boots.
If you heard her come in, it must have been her.
I heard noises, so I thought it was her.
But you also said, reference D66,
"I saw my wife's and Clmence's heads."
Did you see them or didn't you?
Your wife disappeared,
you found her handbag and you said nothing to the police?
I wasn't sure that...
Her purse wasn't in it, so...
I'll remind the court that the handbag did not contain
her purse, her mobile phone,
her chequebook and the prize she won at cards that night.
Jacques, when you found the handbag, you didn't realise it was Suzy's, right?
You have to say so, Jacques.
You didn't. Mum had loads of bags.
They're being dishonest. You said early on that she wasn't in her bed.
Yes, if he had killed her, all he had to say was,
"My daughter's right, she didn't come home." He said the opposite.
We should write memory cards for him,
so he'll say the right thing.
- How do the cops know she went home? - They don't know she's dead.
We know she went home.
There's evidence... Just read the papers.
There's evidence which confirms that she definitely went home.
That's where to start digging.
What matters is what happened next.
Not what happened before.
I called them Monday morning.
When Jacques said she hadn't come home, I said, "I'm coming round."
So Durandet turned up here on the Monday. What did he say?
First we went in the kitchen to...
He drinks coffee, I don't.
I used to make some when he came around.
I said to him, "When she came to the cards tournament,
"she had her toilet bag with her lens stuff."
The bag with the lens stuff.
Did the two of you find it?
It was right next to the sink.
A pair of lenses was missing.
I remember she had that toilet bag
when I dropped her off.
Now it's the boys who use this bathroom.
Then what happened with Durandet?
I left him alone.
Yes, he said he wanted to go in Suzy's bedroom
to check some things.
It's upstairs, next to Clmence's room.
- Did you see the mattress? - It was there on the Monday.
- You're sure? - Yes.
I sat on the sofa bed.
I sat on it.
I checked the alarm on her clock radio.
It was set for a quarter to two in the afternoon.
I'd asked her to call me at two.
But she never called me.
You only found her handbag a week later, right?
It was down there.
But you're sure you talked about it on that Monday?
Yes, we looked for it together.
But we didn't look there.
ric Dupond-Moretti. Please leave a message.
Why would Durandet hurry there to try to prove that Suzy went home?
He convinced everyone she did go home, even Viguier.
Why was he unsure, if he took her home?
If it wasn't Suzy that Viguier heard at 4 a.m., maybe it was Durandet.
He planted the toilet bag and handbag and he set the alarm.
Because if Durandet killed her, he had to make it look like she went home.
That's for sure.
Call me back.
You should write crime novels
All right, Mum?
Going to your trial tomorrow?
- Can you take me to training, then? - Yeah.
I think he strangled her. Strangled or smothered.
I'm acting all tough, talking about this,
but I haven't been able to sleep in my bed for three weeks now.
I sleep on the sofa. I suffocate in my bedroom.
You don't think she could have gone out by...
There's something I've remembered.
The shutter in their room, what used to be their room,
didn't close properly.
It goes all the way down, but a bit of light still gets in.
There are like little holes.
- No, when I saw it... - No, no.
...there was a 20cm gap.
No, no. I'm sure about that
because I had a look when we were there.
Because if it was always blocked in that position...
Anyway, with the article in today's...
...light still gets in. There are like little holes.
No, when I...
...there was a 20cm gap.
I'm sure about that because I had a look when we were there.
- He gave himself away. - Didn't you see my text?
So am I.
You have an overactive imagination.
Trust me one last time!
Hello. Give this to Dupond-Moretti.
- What is it? - It's really important.
I can't stay, I'm really late for work. I'm counting on you!
The school called, I have to take him to the doctor.
I'm sorry, there's nothing I can do.
I was their babysitter.
Suzy was like a big sister to me.
I was really close to her and...
her children. They were very affectionate and...
I didn't see Mr Viguier much.
He was only there sporadically.
He had a lot of activities.
I never managed to relax around him.
When Suzy entrusted her children to me,
she said they were the most precious thing in the world to her.
I can't believe she'd just leave her children.
Is Durandet your brother-in-law?
No, not really, he's my sister's husband's brother.
You were the Viguiers' babysitter, so you had keys?
So you went there on the Monday and had a look around.
What were you looking for?
To see if Suzy's things were there.
To see if she'd gone or not.
conducted your "investigation"
even into Jacques Viguier's bathroom?
I had a quick look.
You had a quick look and in the bathtub you saw blood.
Water mixed with blood.
And of course you mentioned it straight away to Mr Durandet.
I don't know if I did or not.
No, you didn't.
It wasn't until your third statement, nine months later,
that you mentioned it to the police.
Yes, I don't know why, I...
Madam, you are under oath.
I shall put the question to you directly.
Was Durandet with you in the house, on Monday 28th February 2000?
Do you know there are new telephone recordings?
Well, not new, but recently disclosed.
Durandet was not with you?
Not in the house.
He stayed in the car, he didn't come in.
He was there in the car, but he didn't come in?
Are you sure?
Yes, I'd have heard him.
- The recordings contradict you. - Really?
This is important, Madam.
We've been wondering for so long who could have gone in the house,
wondering how a Hitchcockian murderer
would have left his wife's handbag rather than just dump it.
We wondered if maybe the handbag was planted there.
That's all just supposition.
I don't think he came in.
- Can I hear it? - Later.
This is not the time to interrupt me!
We'll listen to it.
I haven't finished my questioning.
Madam, you're a key witness. Excuse me, but one last time,
do you swear that Durandet didn't go in with you?
He came in, but he stayed with me.
- Why have you never said so? - He asked me not to.
In case it was said that he planted something.
Well, he didn't say it like that.
"In case it had consequences on the investigation."
And for ten years it hasn't bothered you?
Yes, but he kept saying it would cause problems.
I was 18, I was easily influenced.
How about the blood, the traces of blood in the bathtub?
Did you see them?
Yes, I did.
So did he, then, if he was with you.
I don't think so.
I'm imploring you to tell us the truth.
You said nothing for ten years,
nothing at the first trial,
and you want us to believe
that you saw blood
but said nothing to Durandet, who was with you?
I never said
that I was sure. I said, "I think..."
Blood is a damning factor.
You can imagine how your declaration
could make things bad for Jacques Viguier.
How your declaration could secure his conviction.
How your declaration
could deprive Clmence, Nicolas and Guillaume of their father.
In life there are moments of truth.
I have a daughter.
I'm afraid of what might happen.
I'll tell you everything. On the Monday I was alone.
Olivier asked to go on the Tuesday.
He wanted to see if Suzy's things were there. He was worried.
He did his "search" when Viguier was there.
I don't believe you about the blood.
- You're not telling the whole truth. - I am now.
You know the conscience with which you leave this court.
I have no further questions, Mr President.
Court will adjourn for thirty minutes.
I save my comments for after the verdict.
What are the consequences of these revelations?
could have done without this disastrous episode.
Isn't he ill?
It doesn't prove the guilt or innocence
of Jacques Viguier, but in the minds of the jurors...
Where's my mum?
No idea. Isn't she supposed to be with you?
...the subornation of witnesses.
It throws doubt on his testimony still to come
and on part of the police investigation.
It is rare in a trial
for a witness to steal the limelight from the accused.
What's going on?
Flix came to the brasserie. You had his stuff.
I couldn't explain on the phone.
The truth is always easier.
He told me everything.
And I saw your psycho wall.
You don't go in, we have rules.
Give it a rest! Don't you realise we were worried?
My battery was dead.
And what's with the "we"? You're not his dad.
- OK, I screwed up, but it was worth it. - Tell your son.
Filou, I'm really sorry.
No, don't get mad.
- It was stupid, I... - Get out!
Leave me alone! Get out!
It was a mad day.
I don't give a toss about your day! Get out!
The lover in custody
He'll be charged, won't he?
It'll never be followed up.
- And the babysitter? - You don't want her in prison?
But something has to happen.
This is Viguier's trial, not Durandet's.
While he was in custody,
we got the chance to talk, just the two of us.
I'm sure he remembers.
I suggested that we go and get the body.
I didn't want a confession.
What we, the investigators, wanted was to find the body.
we had this little chat and...
asked for time to think.
it's hard to describe.
There was a very strange atmosphere.
It was in the eyes...
Then, all of a sudden, I don't know why,
he reverted to his initial attitude.
"I didn't do anything. It wasn't me."
Back to square one. He withdrew into that position.
is it true you offered Jacques Viguier's father a deal,
a dark future for his grandchildren?
How could the police offer a deal in the name of justice?
So it isn't true?
- You deny it? - Absolutely.
I swear it.
- Excuse me... - Mr Viguier!
Sit down, please.
a reconstruction of his supposed "jogging".
- How long did he take? - Thirty minutes.
That's where we have a problem.
Thirty minutes isn't an hour.
Yes, we saw that it didn't match the analysis of the phone data.
At the time he claimed he was jogging,
there was a call to his mother.
It doesn't make sense,
especially as Mr Viguier
has a very good memory.
But there he's lost almost an hour.
The counsel for the defence.
You gambled everything on the husband and got nothing.
Did you investigate the lover?
Olivier Durandet is a victim.
I deplore that he hid things from us,
but it doesn't change our case.
You talk of leads not followed up.
We can't run pointlessly around Toulouse.
We prioritise witness statements,
and everything points to Mr Viguier.
To the husband.
No one provided us with a serious alternative lead.
Neither Mr Viguier, nor his family, nor his friends.
So you have no proof,
just the conviction that he killed her.
My question is simple.
Where, when, how?
These are hypotheses, as I've said.
We lean towards an argument.
He didn't mean to kill his wife. It was an accident.
- Then, after... - After, it was the perfect crime!
No more questions.
Superintendent, thank you.
I suggest we adjourn for today.
Excuse me, Mr President.
I would like
to tell the court about this message.
A woman called, saying she was Suzy's decorator.
She says she knew Olivier Durandet well
and will testify that she believes he could have strangled her.
See how rumour works?
Three hours in custody,
a bit of press coverage, and Durandet's accused of murder.
It was 40 hours for Viguier.
You can imagine the caf gossip.
Court is adjourned
until 9 o'clock tomorrow.
I remember the decorator from the recordings.
She has to testify, doesn't she?
- Didn't you hear me? - She talked about strangling.
Everyone here has blood and the mattress on their mind.
But Durandet talks all the time about strangling.
We have to talk to her, I can do it. What's her number?
Who do you think you are?
You're busting my balls!
We talked about it at school today.
Why would the lover have killed her?
She wanted a divorce, but didn't necessarily want to live with him.
I think he found that out as he drove her back that night.
They were in the car, it was dark, they argued and he strangled her.
- People don't kill like that. - They do. It's a crime of passion.
- Do you know what that is? - No.
It's when things spin out of control
between two people who have strong feelings for each other.
An argument gets out of hand, they lose their temper and so on.
And often, a crime of passion is by strangulation...
Do you never bloody well quit?
I may have something. Want a lift?
No, I need to walk.
In the days after Suzy went missing, Durandet called all her friends,
even people he barely knew or didn't know at all,
whose numbers he shouldn't have had.
And where was Suzy's address book found?
In her handbag.
He even called an old friend of Suzy, some cop he doesn't even know.
Get in and have a listen.
My parents got a phone call on Sunday at 2 p.m.
He asked for a David who knew Suzy. So my mum said yes.
Hang on, who called you?
We don't know. He wouldn't say.
But he pronounced my name wrong.
He pronounced it Gass, so he's not someone who knows me.
He said, "Is that the David who goes out with Ambre?"
Yes, there was a David and Ambre.
I wanted to know who called me. I don't like that.
I thought he'd got hold of an address book,
and I'd follow it up if I had to.
He got the wrong David.
Exactly. He didn't know who he was calling.
The other David was a babysitter.
He was calling everyone.
When was that phone call?
A week after she went missing. Before the handbag was found.
- Here, Matre. - Thank you.
- What was his name again? - David Gasser.
He kept the bag because he needed the numbers.
Then he went and planted it.
You're jumping the gun.
Durandet killed her!
What's the motive?
They don't have a motive for Viguier either!
My job isn't to find a culprit.
OK, Durandet's a serial slanderer, but that doesn't make him a killer.
- If he planted the bag, he killed her. - Not at all.
He just wanted to frame Viguier.
And Suzy could still have just gone.
The accusation is based on one hypothesis.
If we come up with another, the jury will pick the most convincing.
And it won't be yours. The other's been there for ten years.
Doubt isn't about one possibility, but all possibilities.
If you don't get that, I can't help you.
We're losing customers.
- Where are you? - At work.
Can you note where in the recordings you found your selections?
I'd have to listen again from the start.
Can you or not?
It'll take days.
Durandet will appear on Thursday. Richiardi wants the references.
He wants to maintain control. Can you do it?
Get back in the kitchen, we'll talk later.
Cut some bread, please.
I don't have any choice, it has to be now.
I think you've screwed me around enough as it is!
I have big personal problems.
- I can't... - That's enough!
The door's there. Go if you want.
But don't come back.
Where's Nora? Go and get her.
- What time is it? - Nine.
- Shouldn't you be at school? - I start at ten today.
Court is in session.
You may be seated.
Call Mr Durandet.
Tell us your full name, age and profession.
My name is Olivier Durandet,
and I'm a sales events organiser.
Do you swear to tell the whole truth?
Raise your right hand and say, "I swear."
this trip to the house with the babysitter?
If you're asking if I went back in the house with her,
the answer is yes.
I also told her not to say anything about it.
But the reason was because...
if Jacques knew, I wouldn't get to hear any news
or get any phone numbers.
The numbers for Suzy's sisters, for example.
I didn't have them.
I had numbers for her card-playing and dance contacts, but...
Was it a quick visit to the house?
She kept saying, "This is pretty weird."
She also said she was scared.
It wasn't a very honest thing to do, but...
I certainly couldn't make my living as a burglar
because my heart was beating like mad.
what were we looking for?
Just something to reassure me, really.
To see if she'd taken any of her things.
The wardrobe was full.
But I didn't take or plant anything.
Not at all.
I understand why the defence wants to sow that idea
because it's something very compromising for his client.
He knows because the first person to tell him
was me... When you wanted to represent me.
- No. - Oh, yes.
- No! - You're embarrassed.
I am not, and I will tell you!
It was you who came to me in Lille!
Me? I've never been to Lille.
You are a liar!
You're a liar and a manipulator!
You manipulated the Toulouse police, but not me.
- Of course! - You came to me.
And I turned you away.
Don't get in such a state.
No, Matre, we're not falling for this.
I know it's your job, but...
Mr President, check my diary...
This isn't the court's remit.
I have the same phone, you can...
- That's enough! - Continue the questioning.
Matre Dupond-Moretti, Mr Durandet.
- Of course. - Sir.
You made a lot of phone calls, including to people you didn't know.
Do you remember trying to call a certain...
at his parents' home?
Is it someone I know, or did someone give me his number?
During your call you said
that Mrs Viguier gave you the number a year before.
It seems you were trying to contact another David.
I don't remember.
Where's the Gasser recording?
Did you give it to me?
Yes, last week.
Shit, I don't have last week's!
I want to talk about Gasser.
I talked about that earlier.
How did you come to have in your possession
the number of a man you didn't know and who didn't know you,
since he called you Durat?
I don't know.
Please show the jurors the handbag
which was found in the wardrobe
with Suzy's address book.
You're looking for a David.
I'll play the calls.
- I haven't finished. - We'll listen.
I asked for the handbag, not the calls.
I asked that question earlier.
I'm sorry, but I'm leading up to something.
Leading up to what? Out with it!
- The handbag. - You want the handbag.
- Please look in her address book. - Yes.
- Under "G". - Yes, David Gasser is there.
So, where did you find that phone number?
I have no idea.
Someone must have given it to me.
Who and why?
- Hello? - Jacques?
- Yes. - It's Olivier.
- Olivier. - All right?
I'm with the police so...
Did that David call you back?
A guy named David called.
I passed him to the police.
It was me who contacted him.
I thought it was David the babysitter.
It's better if you tell the police all this yourself.
Hello, this is...
I was telling him that I contacted David
because Suzy gave me that number over a year ago.
But I didn't think I'd get that David.
I thought it'd be the David who's a babysitter.
I think you got all your answers there.
I don't remember that conversation at all.
I won't just make stuff up.
I said I'd had the number for over a year, from Suzy.
I don't know why, but...
Richiardi keeps thwarting me.
- What's our biggest bullet? - The children.
- How long does it last? - 17 minutes, I think.
Find where he talks about them suffering.
The charger's in the car.
Hurry, I need it!
Mum, I've called the fire service.
I'm waiting outside the flats. Call me back.
- Mum! - What's going on?
Don't worry, Mum, I'm OK.
Don't move, Madam.
Madam, do you hear me?
We're carrying out some tests.
I have to call my son.
Yes, you can call him.
It's OK, I don't care about the kitchen.
Don't cry, it doesn't matter.
I'll see you later.
Has your role in this been exaggerated?
The best way to divert suspicion is to accuse someone else.
Can you turn it up, please?
He was very straightforward.
He admitted where he'd gone wrong.
I don't think anyone could now suspect Durandet.
On the other hand, all the charges against Viguier still remain.
There are hundreds of hours of recordings.
Asking to play extracts shouldn't be a problem.
I allowed your request, I'm not responsible for the technology.
No, we will not carry on like that tomorrow!
At some point I'll say enough!
What's going on?
- What happened to you? - Nothing.
Just a bit of a fright.
- Are you sure you're OK? - Yes.
Tell me what happened.
We should prepare the children for a guilty verdict.
- Where is he? - In the bedroom.
What did the doctor say?
- Did they do a scan? - Yeah.
They don't care about the truth.
They're going to condemn an innocent man.
Yeah, we'll do it tomorrow.
It's a drawing that my brothers and I did.
There's "alive" and "dead".
It hurts to see him here...
when it's just one branch.
She loved us, I'm sure of that.
We don't want to believe she just left, but it's possible.
Even if it means she abandoned us,
I prefer to believe Mum's alive.
There's no evidence that...
she's not alive.
The statement of the 10-year-old Clmence Viguier.
"I remember that Sunday in the middle of the holidays.
"I got up and Mummy hadn't come home."
I don't remember.
I can see myself in her bed,
but I don't know if she's there.
The trial of Jacques Viguier.
The prosecution has begun its summing up.
The verdict is expected tomorrow.
Who'll stand up for Suzy?
Not her husband, he cheated on her. Not her children,
they've chosen their father over justice. Who can blame them?
No. The only one
to show any interest in Suzy
was Olivier Durandet.
That's why they tried to besmirch him.
Rue des Corbires.
26th February 2000, at 4 a.m.
With his hands.
A miscarriage of justice
also means when it is denied to victims.
How could you betray Suzy? By denying her justice.
Come in. I couldn't tell you everything over the phone.
The relationship was being torn apart.
Jacques Viguier knew he'd lose the divorce.
I still think, like at the first trial, that he murdered her.
You think he could have strangled her?
It probably happened
at 4:30 a.m.
We cannot exclude the possibility that Clmence awoke next to her mother
three hours later. I don't know.
Exercise your imagination.
Olivier is strong.
He could have carried Suzy to the sofa bed, to frame the husband.
He'd have had to get rid of the body.
I think Viguier chopped her up. He's a hunter.
I once saw him butcher a deer in the garden.
- Call me back any time. - Yes.
I know stuff no one else knows.
They wanted to open a nightclub.
He was going to leave his job and do that with Suzy.
It's Nora. I know the motive.
This is a nightmare, I don't believe it!
I'll stay here all night.
You can't do this to me, I'm doing my summing up tomorrow!
There's a motive.
Durandet had a business plan, he needed Suzy's divorce money.
If Suzy left him, he'd have lost everything.
You don't understand the law, you're dangerous!
You could do to Durandet what was done to Viguier for ten years!
Don't you see? The motive he attributed to Viguier was his own.
His status, the way others see him...
Durandet was talking about himself! He'd have lost everything!
Legally, you've got nothing! Fuck all!
Now get out of my sight and let me get some sleep!
Look at yourself.
Your hatred is like theirs. The same look as the superintendent.
You're another little Durandet.
Matre Dupond-Moretti, whenever you're ready.
A few hours from now,
case number 3436
will have run its course.
It will be filed with other cases in the national archive.
It'll be time for the next trial.
You will go home,
having sealed the fate of a man.
How can I put this?
I don't like this trial.
Firstly because I'm probably the last voice to speak for a man
who has lost his own.
Also, and above all,
because I'm having to fight against people's imagination.
because of the investigation's blindness and deficiencies,
has become the World Cup of different hypotheses.
In the morning!
No, at night!
Use your imagination, go on!
We're totally removed
from any sort of methodology.
It's a Kafkaesque trial.
A surreal trial.
The only question,
the only one...
Is there a single proof
of Jacques Viguier's guilt?
It's not your job to dream up hypotheses.
This hard work should have been done,
with their sleeves rolled up, by the police.
What if she simply went away?
What if she's still alive? What if she hasn't come back?
What do the police have to say?
"It is not implausible..."
"It is probable..."
"I still think..."
The day the police's conviction is enough
will be the day justice dies and we'll just go off to bed.
They've hedged their bets
Viguier is clever when he dumps the mattress,
but an idiot for keeping the handbag.
Of course he realised
that he shouldn't have thrown the mattress away,
that the police took that as evidence of his guilt.
He realised that it's hard to explain why we do odd things.
But the psychiatrists told you that throwing away that mattress
was a rejection.
An emotional act.
In so many divorces people take it out on material things.
The mattress is like a partner's car, no more nor less.
that there's been something hellish about this.
It's like a bullfight.
We're not allowing Viguier to be what we are every single day.
Because he crossed the Rubicon, because he killed,
because he's a murderer?
That's what the police told us!
So you have a choice
between the superintendent and...
who was told...
"Go and see your son and get him to confess.
"Because if he doesn't,
"your little Clmence,
"will become a whore.
"Guillaume and Nicolas will end up junkies."
Weren't his superiors outraged by that?
Wasn't the public prosecutor outraged?
Shame on you!
Ladies and gentlemen of the jury,
during this trial I sensed that you were
captivated by the phone calls.
Consider that the superintendent paid no attention to them.
Neither did the investigating judge or his entire chambers.
We had to work through them, ten years too late,
going through hundreds of hours, to discover that Durandet lied.
I am not the prosecutor and it is not up to me to demonstrate
But if we're in the domain of doubt,
is it impossible that Durandet went back to plant the handbag
in order to frame Viguier?
It's only a hypothesis.
But there are so many.
It was a lovely day that Sunday.
At about 1 p.m. Suzy woke up, alone in the house.
We can very easily picture her getting dressed,
putting her lenses in,
getting her mobile phone,
her chequebook and other papers,
going out, walking away...
I don't know about the rest.
And it is not my place to say anything at all about that.
But what I do know,
what I can assert,
is that she could have gone out!
"Circumstances of disappearance.
"Sunday 27th February, between 10 a.m. and 6 p.m."
There, that's what the police wrote.
Between 10 o'clock and 6 o'clock she could have gone out.
Every year there's a large number
of unexplained disappearances.
I envy those legal soothsayers who are unassailed by doubt.
I... don't know.
He hasn't been shown much kindness.
This man has been paying for ten years
for a crime of which a court has already acquitted him.
Look at his perp face!
Filmed from afar, filmed from up close!
Let's humiliate him!
Let's trample on him!
Let's have no respect for the presumption of innocence!
How is it possible to live like that for ten years?
The looks cast by neighbours,
by colleagues, by people at the university!
Being held in custody!
Being deprived of his freedom!
The first trial and the disgusting comments which followed that!
Say something! Move!
Justice, Mr President, is first and foremost
the signature of those who dispense it.
Before being a collective decision, it is an individual decision.
It's you, Sir.
A profound conviction, says the law, is based on evidence.
And a miscarriage of justice is not an accident.
It's wilfully playing fast and loose with our principles.
If you condemn with a total absence of proof,
then you will have judged...
but you will not have dispensed justice.
Thank you, Matre.
Mr Viguier, do you have anything to add in your defence?
It's been ten years of hell.
Do not make my whole world collapse.
Please restore my dignity as a man,
for my children
and for Suzy.
The bench will withdraw.
you must remain here while we deliberate.
I shall ask the journalists and cameramen to leave.
Court is adjourned.
Ladies and gentlemen,
You may be seated.
They looked over at him!
Mr Viguier, please stand.
To questions 1 and 2, the jury has answered no,
making question 3 null and void.
The court declares Jacques Viguier not guilty.
The hearing is over.
Wait for me.
Suzanne Viguier's death has never been confirmed.
In France, over 40,000 people disappear every year.
10,000 are never accounted for.
Apart from Jacques Viguier, who is now definitively acquitted,
no other protagonist of case 3436 has been charged.
Inspired by the case, this film includes several fictional elements.
The character of Nora and her profound conviction are invented.
Subtitles by Howard Bonsor